The Watchmen movie

Randolph Carter's picture

Just because someone had to say it, it looks freaking awesome from the trailer up on H&R.

__________________

But, as Deepak Chopra taught us, quantum physics means anything can happen at any time for no reason! Also, eat plenty of oatmeal, and animals never had a war... who's the real animal?

=Professor Farnsworth

Aresen's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Just tried to watch the trailer a few moments ago. My $#%^$#^& machine won't download it.

__________________

If you weren't doing anything wrong, then you have no reason to be afraid while they kick the crap out of you. - D.A. Ridgely

Randolph Carter's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Well you'd best get to a machine that plays it, I haven't seen a trailer like that since that one with "Lux Aeterna" for The Two Towers.

When Dr. Manhattan dissipates - *shivers*

__________________

But, as Deepak Chopra taught us, quantum physics means anything can happen at any time for no reason! Also, eat plenty of oatmeal, and animals never had a war... who's the real animal?

=Professor Farnsworth

Shem's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

BITCHIN'

__________________

I CAUTION YOU / IN DEFEATING ORCS WE MAY FIND THE ONLY VILLAIN LEFT TO FACE IS OUR OWN PREJUDICE--qwantz.com

Eric the .5b's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

I am stoked.

Jadagul's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Randolph Carter wrote:
Well you'd best get to a machine that plays it, I haven't seen a trailer like that since that one with "Lux Aeterna" for The Two Towers.

When Dr. Manhattan dissipates - *shivers*

I realize this is completely irrelevant to anything, but when has that ever stopped anyone on this board? My big dance solo in the dance concert this year was to the "Lux Aeterna" theme from the Two Towers trailer. I have a rather soft spot for it in my heart.

Warren's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Making comics into movies is just about the only thing working for Hollywood anymore. And half the time, they still fail. I never did the comic book sorry graphic novel thing. I'm not familiar with The Watchmen. To me the trailer looks like just another superhero in the summer of superhero.

__________________

seriously though, i think you're crazy on this. and you think i'm crazy. everybody wins! - dhex

Eric the .5b's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Warren wrote:
Making comics into movies is just about the only thing working for Hollywood anymore. And half the time, they still fail. I never did the comic book sorry graphic novel thing. I'm not familiar with The Watchmen. To me the trailer looks like just another superhero in the summer of superhero.

Hard to explain without going into fanboy "OMG let me tell you about this great thing you MUST MUST read" mode (which sounds like a waste of your time), but Watchmen was basically the classic deconstruction of superheroes by Alan Moore. It and Dark Knight Returns influenced much lesser hands to create the Grim N' Gritty age of comics.

I actually kinda wonder how mainstream audiences will react to it.

Shem's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Eric the .5b wrote:
I actually kinda wonder how mainstream audiences will react to it.

I wonder how they're going to have it make sense without all the data dumps that come in the newspaper articles, scrapbooks, incident reports, &c. that are scattered through the comic.

__________________

I CAUTION YOU / IN DEFEATING ORCS WE MAY FIND THE ONLY VILLAIN LEFT TO FACE IS OUR OWN PREJUDICE--qwantz.com

Eric the .5b's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Shem wrote:
Eric the .5b wrote:
I actually kinda wonder how mainstream audiences will react to it.

I wonder how they're going to have it make sense without all the data dumps that come in the newspaper articles, scrapbooks, incident reports, &c. that are scattered through the comic.

I think that's doable, but I suspect it'll be tricky.

EDIT: to be fair, I was mystified as to how they'd get the V for Vendetta story to fit in a movie, but they hit the vital points.

dead_elvis's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

I coincidentally just finished reading Watchmen. I was overall pretty impressed. A little disappointed in some crucial things towards the end. I found Dr. Manhattan's revelation with Laurie to be pretty weak, I also thought that the whole giant psychic octopus teleported into New York felt, I dunno, not right. Too gimmicky or something. I know it's a super-hero comic, but it did such a great job building up its premise and its world, that when something doesn't seem spot on it sticks out.

I'm curious how they are going to work the Pirate story into it. Leaving it out would be a shame.

__________________

"They civilize left, They civilize right
Till nothing is left, Till nothing is right"

Eric the .5b's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

I am waiting to come across the first accusations that Watchmen rips off The Incredibles.

dhex's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

remember to savor it when you find it.

__________________

"Yeah, but my character would be all swav and deboner." - Warren

D.A. Ridgely's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Eric the .5b wrote:
I am waiting to come across the first accusations that Watchmen rips off The Incredibles.

I hear Watchmen rips off The Incredibles big time. Just sayin'.

__________________

"love is like porn, you know" -- Ali

Number 6's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

My prediction: the movie will be a slap in the face to Alan Moore.

__________________

"Nothing is at last sacred but the integrity of your own mind... I am ashamed to think how easily we capitulate to badges and names, to large societies and dead institutions.."-Emerson

Shem's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Number 6 wrote:
My prediction: the movie will be a slap in the face to Alan Moore.

What're you going to predict next, that the sun will rise tomorrow? :p Alan Moore hates all comic book movies, especially the ones based on his books. He's already pissy because of some comments that the filmmakers made, which doesn't bode well for his feelings about it when it comes out.

__________________

I CAUTION YOU / IN DEFEATING ORCS WE MAY FIND THE ONLY VILLAIN LEFT TO FACE IS OUR OWN PREJUDICE--qwantz.com

dhex's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

i thought moore hated all that stuff a priori?

__________________

"Yeah, but my character would be all swav and deboner." - Warren

Mo's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Number 6 wrote:
My prediction: the movie will be a slap in the face to Alan Moore.

It can't be worse than Watchmen Babies on V for Vacation.

__________________

If you don't want to be arrested by the Park Police, don't go to the Jefferson Memorial.

mediageek's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Quote:
My prediction: the movie will be a slap in the face to Alan Moore.

Moore will take it as such, regardless of how the movie turns out. FWIW, I have confidence in Zak Snyder to be able to pull this off.

__________________

Brought to you by Carl's Jr.

Lost_In_Translation's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

I'll admit, I'm halfway through the "novel" and I'm completely stoked about this movie now!!!

__________________

Proud Cosmotarian

Lost_In_Translation's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Damnit, finished the novel and was sorely disappointed. :(

__________________

Proud Cosmotarian

Shem's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Over what, exactly?

__________________

I CAUTION YOU / IN DEFEATING ORCS WE MAY FIND THE ONLY VILLAIN LEFT TO FACE IS OUR OWN PREJUDICE--qwantz.com

Lost_In_Translation's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

Alot, spoilers in white

Ozymadius's poor reasoning (and marginal intelligence)

Jon's lack of consistancy and shitty reasoning

Tachyons

Dreiburg's "go along to get along"ism

Laurie's flakiness

Book ending before events proved Ozymandias to be completely full of shit

Rorchach's exploding (only character that proved to be really interesting, aside from 'pre-Laurie on Mars' Jon)

The pirate story not fitting in with the actual story (though that in itself was not too terribly bad)

Writers and artists on island

That's about it.

__________________

Proud Cosmotarian

D.A. Ridgely's picture

Re: The Watchmen movie

I read the book in response to the movie buzz and, *shrug*, competition for the Hugo was light that year? (Actually, I can't recall a Hugo winner in years and years that I thought was worthy.) It's not a superhero book, the guy from the Blue Man Group aside. Remove the spandex and it's a graphic novel version of I don't know how many film noir movies and pulp fiction novels. It wasn't actually bad but it wasn't actually good, either. So, would one or more of its obviously many, many fans like to tell me what I'm missing?

__________________

"love is like porn, you know" -- Ali